Home › Forums › Doc Martin Rewatch › Doc Martin Rewatch – Series 3 › Episode 1 – The Apple Doesn't Fall
This topic contains 156 replies, has 4 voices, and was last updated by Retta 7 years, 10 months ago.
-
AuthorPosts
-
Post your comments for The Apple Doesn’t Fall here
-
I’ve been away…and am happy to be jumping back into one of my all time favorite episodes. I thought this was well written and well played from the first scene to the last. Loved the beginning with “prince ” Martin coming to the rescue.
My feelings are that this episode was Doc Martin at its best with the classic gruff bedside manner. He is an equal offender to the blind, the elderly,the overweight… Nobody is safe. The banter between the doc and Ms Lane was laugh out loud funny several times, as was his treatment of Mr Cleary…walking him into a wall, then shouting at him as if he was also hearing impaired. Even the guide dog got laughs with his perfectly timed growls. Later he tells Burt that he’s past his prime, and insults Aunt Joan be referring to Mr Cleary as her “victim”. His interaction with Louisa is also a classic with his confusion to her objections to his personal medical questions. They seem to always be on a different page of the same book.
Additionally we see the introduction of Britains own Barney Fife, joe Penhale.
I found this episode a perfect set up for a series of a more vulnerable Martin where Louisa was concerned.In my opinion this one was as good as it gets. Bravo!
-
UnityThat ins’thgis perfect for what I need. Thanks!
-
-
SueI heartily agree with the previous comments.
This is one of my favorite episodes and a great start to S3, one of my favorite series.
It has a little bit of everything…the grumpy Doc with his multiple verbal duels with Allison Lane, the romantic Martin as he and Louisa finally start to realize they are making a connection, the bewildered Martin who does not understand what he has said to upset Louisa, the extraordinary Doc who comes to the rescue to save Delph’s life, the surprisingly understanding and practical Doc who encourages Pauline to obtain some medical training as a phlebotomist to give her additional responsibility and relieve him of a task made difficult by his hemophobia, plus some good physical comedy and many great one-liners.
I found the introduction to be quite clever with the analogy of Martin and Louisa’s situation to a fairy tale romance. It applies not only to this episode, but carries throughout the series until the bubble bursts in S3E8. The scenes were well-chosen to match the fairy tale that Louisa was reading to the children. The passers-by on the streets of Port Wenn could easily be construed as a dragon, a wizard and a goblin. Naturally, there is Gremlin, “the faithful hound”. And the children encircling Louisa represent the princess imprisoned in the castle. The prince (Martin) leaps over a bench to “scale the castle wall” to come to her aid.
There were so many great lines during the confrontations between Martin and Allison Lane:
A: “You haven’t told me what’s wrong with her yet.”
M: “She’s very annoying.”M: “Good-bye Mrs. Lane.”
A: “It’s not Mrs. I’m divorced.”
M: “I’m not surprised.”M: “Why is MS Lane reorganizing my diary? Patients do not come into this surgery without my invitation.”
A: “And yet here I am!”M: “….No, you have come here to ask me to sedate your child so you can pretend she is a good little girl.”
A: “She IS a good little girl.”
M: “There’s nothing LITTLE about her.”And the conversation between Bert and the Doc:
B: “Why do you think I’m unhappy all the time? I know that’s a hard one.”
M: “No it isn’t. You’re lonely, bored, unloved and past your prime, if you ever had a prime.”This series, for a reason I never understood, has two titles for each episode…one for UK viewers and a different one for U.S. viewers. I try to understand the significance of the titles, but I may not be creative enough to pick them out. The UK title of “Tick Tock”, I presume could reference not only the Doc’s hobby, which he may be ready to give up as it “may be time for something new”, but possibly Louisa’s biological clock that’s ticking. She tells Bert that she would like to have lots of children when “I find the right man.” Does the U.S. title of “The Apple Doesn’t Fall” relate to the major story line of this episode with Allison Lane and her daughter Delph, both of whom are fat?
I especially enjoyed two scenes with Martin and Louisa…the one in the surgery where he examines her and suspects she is anemic and the one at the end where she tells him she is worried about what she is doing with her life. There is such promise that perhaps M&L will eventually manage to get together.
All in all, it is a well-crafted episode and sets the stage well for the rest of this series.
-
I noticed the line when Allison told him she isn’t “Mrs” because she’s divorced, but found it strange because most divorced women continue to use the title “Mrs”. But reading your quotes hit me. I hadn’t noticed that Martin apparently was paying attention because he remembered when he saw her again to refer to her as “Ms”. Is this the one time when he went above and beyond to remember a patient’s name? In this case, her title?
-
SueYes, it is somewhat surprising that he would even care about name or title, but he definitely emphasizes the “MS” when he says it, as if making a point.
-
LuckRight on-hits helped me sort things right out.
-
PhilindaA piece of eritudion unlike any other!
-
Disney -
Latasha -
Augustina -
Augustina -
Keydrick -
Honeysuckle
-
-
LizaPecrfet answer! That really gets to the heart of it!
-
-
VinnySuper inatmrfoive writing; keep it up.
-
AmberleeWhy do I bother calilng up people when I can just read this!
-
Amber -
Charlotte -
Beyonce -
Cherlin -
Storm -
Carajean -
Voncile
-
-
I love this episode – it really sets up a lot of things that extend well past S3.
There are bookends for the end of S2E8 and this episode (I think of “On the Edge” as a little outside the series). The last shot of Erotomania ends with the helicopter pulling up away from the village and heading down the coast to the west. This episode starts with a helicopter shot coming back up the coast from the west and turning into the harbor. Ben Bolt had to have thought that out.
I agree about how wonderful that initial fairy tale scene was, and no matter how much Martin & Philippa insist it isn’t a fairy tale, they wink at us every time they hint at it. One of my favorite ones two series later is Mrs T (Rapunzel) in the tower (Louisa also played Rapunzel in this episode).
Just about every conversation between M&L in this episode reveals Martin’s soft, “Louisa” voice. Even when he was upset with her about suggesting the Ritalin he never raised his voice.
Great continuity! In this initial episode for Joe Penhale, he tells Martin he was married and lived in Bude. Two series later (4 years later), his wife appears traveling from Bude.
The last scene in this episode is one of my absolute favorite scenes. The beginning is so comical with Louisa acting like a schoolmarm to both Alison and Martin. Again, Martin takes her direction without getting his back up. And then it becomes so sweet and romantic. Great writing!
This episode set in motion many of the show’s future storylines. Martin was the catalyst for two characters’ change of careers: Bert getting into the restaurant business and Pauline studying phlebotomy – which eventually led to her leaving Portwenn to pursue other opportunities in the medical field. And we are introduced to Penhale, with Martin (after prodding from Aunt Joan) helping him to overcome his issues so he can become an effective constable for the village.
But the main story that is really set in motion this episode is M&L’s love story. It got off to a rocky start in Erotomania after they kissed and professed their love for each other and Martin ruined it as is his wont. Now they seem to have settled into real actual courting. Martin is being so gentle with her and they are both getting to know each other. Martin feels comfortable enough around her to stick his face right into her chest when he mashes her prawn sandwich. This is the beginning of a truly magical series. I know a lot of people look back at S3 and ask why it can’t get back to that. But my feeling is that the initial falling in love time is a time that you just can’t ever get back to. Every couple has it happen only once and as time moves on they must become different people as life experiences change us all. Now they are parents of a young child, married partners, been through breakups and reconciliations, the loss of Martin’s beloved aunt and his father, the realization of his mother’s treachery, Louisa giving up her head teacher role, living in London for a bit, struggles to get her position back, etc. They are much different people now than they were in this episode – it’s what happens to all of us through the years as we are shaped by events in our lives. So, I guess what I’m saying is that we can never have the wonderfulness that is this episode back, but it’s so great that we have it to look back on. The story of M&L that really got going in this episode still moves me and keeps me coming back for more.
-
SueI think all of your observations are right-on. I had to go back and look again at the ending and beginning of those episodes, but I see what you mean about the filming of the village. I tend to simply sit back and enjoy the scenery without thinking of any significance, but it does seem likely that it was planned that way.
Your explanation of why things can’t go back to how they were in S3 makes sense. If it did, then this really would be a fairy tale; real life doesn’t usually work that way. However, as they have reached the end of S7, it seems almost as if M&L have gone full circle, but with some maturing having taken place in the meantime (if it is appropriate to consider people their age as maturing). They have both realized that some of their expectations have been unrealistic and each has identified compromises they can make in order for them to be together. I don’t think it is unrealistic for the writers to permit M&L to be more settled in their relationship…at least as settled as two very different personalities can be.
-
CharleeYou’ve really imssepred me with that answer!
-
-
This episode had another medical storyline which was fresh and relevant. The over prescribing of Ritalin for children and abuse of diet drugs was addressed very well. Other current medical issues have been Louisa’s anti-vaccination comments, infertility, the recurrence of tuberculosis, a disease once thought cured. It is interesting to see these issues pop up rather than OCD, diabetes, and similar standard illnesses.
-
BrynellFelt so hopeless looking for answers to my qun.niotss..uetil now.
-
HannahThat’s 2 clever by half and 2×2 clever 4 me. Thkasn!
-
Cassandra -
Tamber -
Affinity -
Bertha -
Birdie -
Jacoby -
AuthorPosts