.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Trivia - S4E1
Better the Devil
.
Portwenn Online
A Magical Cornish Village
Doc Martin is
IN
.
.
Literary Reference - "Better the devil you know than the devil you don't know" is a proverb of Irish origin and
traces back to a collection of proverbs from 1539.  It means that it is better to deal with something bad that you
know than with something new that you don't know - the new thing might be even worse.
Connecting the Episode Title to the Storylines
Martin has been drifting for several months after Louisa has left the village.  He has recently been trying to
conquer his blood phobia when he runs into Edith.  Edith was his first love - his only love until Louisa.  Even
though things ended badly between Martin and Edith, he seems to be considering whether Edith might be the
answer for him to recover from his breakup with Louisa.  Edith is the "devil he knows".  
Even though Louisa only appears in the last scene, we see that she is apparently happy to see Martin again and
that she is pregnant.  Although we will not see how that scene progresses until the next episode, the viewer is left
wondering:  Will Martin decided to move toward Edith (the devil he knows) or toward Louisa and her pregnancy
(the devil he doesn't know)?  Although he knows and loves Louisa, is he ready to accept her back and dive into
parenthood - which is the "devil he doesn't know"?
Al keeps trying to get Pauline to move in with him and his dad.  Even though Pauline is going crazy with her
brother's snoring since he moved back in, she is willing to put up with her brother (the devil she knows), than to
take the leap to move in with Al.  She only relents at the end of the episode because she is so sleep-deprived.
Edith's treatment of Barbara Collingsworth was a case of her making an assumption that her symptoms fit into a
pattern that she has seen many times, so she failed to follow proper medical procedures.  The diagnosis she came
up with fit into her gynecological speciality (the devil she knows) so she didn't bother to make sure that it wasn't
something simpler - something that could be treated by a GP. (This COULD be a stretch)
One more thing - Edith really could be considered a "devil" in this whole Series 4 story arc.
.
.
Original Broadcast:  Sep 30, 2009

EASTER EGGS - Martin is introduced to Mrs Tishell's husband Clive and he responds that he assumed he was dead.  This could be a callback
to S2E9 (On the Edge) when Martin meets Louisa's father and says he thought he was dead.

EASTER EGGS - When Edith walks into the surgery for the first time she tells Pauline that she needs to see Martin.  When Pauline tries to
explain that he is seeing patients and she will have to wait her turn, Edith pulls rank and says, "I'm Dr Montgomery."  Pauline repiles, "I'm
Pauline, the receptionist".  This is reminiscent of S1E2 (Gentlemen Prefer) when Martin visits Roger in the hospital and parks in the doctors'
lot.  He tells the receptionist, "Dr. Martin Ellingham, Portwenn."  She says, "You're a GP?" and his response is, "Right, yes.  And you're a
receptionist."

ACTION MARTIN - Martin walks through the village carrying the bag of dripping liver.  More and more dogs start following him until he finally
has to start running as he nears the surgery.

ACTION MARTIN - Martin runs to the school to treat the girl with the pencil piercing her temple.

ACTION MARTIN - Martin runs to attend to Barbara after she runs into Clive on her bicycle.

ACTION MARTIN - Martin defies hospital rules and takes Barbara from her pre-op bed to have a CT scan.

FOOD - Aunt Joan brings Martin a pie that she made.

HAEMOPHOBIA - Martin gags as he is carrying the bag of liver through the village, gags when he makes it to the consulting room, gags as he
takes it out of the bag, again when he starts to cut into it, and then vomits after Aunt Joan knocks on his window.

HAEMOPHOBIA - Martin gags several times at the school when he sees the girl impaled by the pencil.  He also gags as he removes it from her
face.

HAEMOPHOBIA - At the scene of Barbara's accident, Martin gags at the sight of his hand after he has cut it on the broken bottle.

HAEMOPHOBIA - While at the hospital, Martin gags when he sees blood on the bandage on his hand.  That's right at the moment he first sees
Edith, and after greeting her, gags again.

HAEMOPHOBIA - Martin is sitting at his desk and testing himself by pricking his finger to draw blood.  But even that drop of blood affects him.

HAEMOPHOBIA - As he is cleaning out Clive's ear, Martin gags at the sight of blood on the cotton.

HAEMOPHOBIA - Martin reacts by holding his breath when Edith unwraps his hand to check on the wound.

MRS TISHELL - Martin stops in to pick up supplies and Mrs Tishell immediately unbuttons the top button of her jacket.  She tries to engage
him in conversation about people who eat paper, dirt, etc and then agrees with him when he calls it half-baked sensationalism.  Clive walks
down the stairs and is reluctantly introduced to Martin.

MRS TISHELL - She has brought Clive to the surgery for his bleeding ear.  After Martin finds that he will be able to cure Clive's hearing loss so
he can go back on the boats, as Mrs Tishell is leaving, she tells Martin (seductively, as only she can) that Clive will soon be gone, far away,
and that she will be all on her own again.  

NICE MARTIN - Buddy follows Martin up Roscarrock Hill to the surgery.  After he shuts the door on him, he opens it again, looks around, and
next you see him driving him back out to Aunt Joan's farm.

RADIOS - The radio is on top of the cabinet behind Pauline's desk.

RUDE MARTIN - Martin is at the hospital and walks past an old woman in a wheelchair trying to use a vending machine.  She asks, "Would you
help me please?" and as he breezes by, he gruffly says, "No."  A few minutes later, he is walking past her again.  Now she is on her feet taking
her coffee from the machine and Martin takes the wheelchair from behind her and takes off to get Barbara.  You just know that the woman is
going to sit back down expecting the wheelchair to be right behind her!
.
.
QUOTES
Martin
Aunt Joan
Martin
Aunt Joan
Martin
Aunt Joan
What's that?
It's a dog.  And it's with me.
Why?
Well, you remember my neighbor Sam?
No.
No.  Well, it doesn’t matter because he's dead.  Someone had to take care of Buddy, so here we are.  
Martin
Aunt Joan
Martin
I do not wish my home and my practice polluted by microcontaminants.
What has he got there?
Well, that's not the point, is it?  It's clearly not his!  
Pauline
Bert
Pauline
It's pitch dark.  You can't relax cause you know it's gonna start again.  You just don't know when.
I had a sheep that snored.
It’s the silence that kills you.  
Bert
Martin
Bert
Martin
Bert

Martin
Bert
Oh Doc.  There just was one other thing that I wanted to discuss with you.  I've got this feeling.
A suspicious feeling?
No, no.  Its; more like when you're travelling by train.
I see.
Well, you got your newspaper, and you got your tea.  But you just can't settle because you're not where you want to be
yet.
Do you have any chest pain, dizziness, or nausea?  Then pull up your trousers and go away.
Doc, Doc, Doc.  Just bear me out, right?  There's something wrong.  It's like a piece missing.  In matters of the heart
Doc.  You know what I'm talking about.  Except YOU know what piece is missing.  
Martin
Pauline
Martin
Pauline
Martin
Pauline
Martin
Pauline
I'm with a patient.
I know.
And you don't interrupt me when I'm with a patient.
I know.
Then you'll also know to turn around, walk away, and close the door.
Fine.  We'll just let her bleed to death then.  Save you the trip.
What?
There's an emergency at the school.
Mr Strain
Martin
Mr Strain
Student
Mr Strain
Martin
Mr Strain
Student
Mr Strain
Martin
Would you like to know why? Would you?
Would I what?
This is why we don't run in corridors.
I want my pencil back.
There could be brain damage.
It hasn't gone into her brain.
You can't see anything from over here.
It's my favorite pencil.
Parents sue for this sort of thing.  What are you doing?  Why don't you do something?
I'm assessing.  
Mrs Tishell

Martin
Mrs Tishell
Clive

Mrs Tishell
Martin
Mrs Tishell
Here's your soap, Dr Ellingham.  I was reading a fascinating article about pica.  That's when people, um,  have a
compulsion to eat dirt, paper, and other things they shouldn't…Oh, sorry.  You know that, of course, don't you?  Sorry.  
Half baked sensationalism.  A box of gloves, please.
Well, that's exactly what I thought.  Half baked sensationalism.
I'll be heading out now!  Pay the papers.  Take the bottles for recycling.  Oh!  I'll put the lottery on!  Well, you never
know!
This is Clive. My husband.
Oh.  I'd assumed he was dead.
No.  He is here.  
Clive
Mrs Tishell
Clive
Sal talks about you all the time.
Not all the time.
Anything I should be worried about, huh?  
Martin
Mrs Tishell
Martin
Clive
Mrs Tishell
Lidocane.
Uh, 1 or 2 percent Doctor?
Two.  Thank you.
Won't be long.
Clive's only here for a couple of weeks, Doctor.  
Village Girls
Oh, how sweet.  Don’t kill that one too! (dog)
Martin
Aunt Joan
Martin
Aunt Joan
Barbara
Martin
Barbara
Martin
All right.  Get out.  Get out!  Get…out!
Buddy!  Where was he?
Making a flea ridden nuisance of himself at my surgery.
What?  He ran all that way?
Must be really fond of you.
It's a dog.  It eats.  It smells.
Some of my best friends are dogs.
You have my sympathy.  
Barbara
Aunt Joan
Martin
Aunt Joan
Martin
Aunt Joan
Barbara

Martin
Barbara
Martin
Communication, understanding.  That's all it is really.
Barbara is a behavioral therapist.
Fascinating.  Goodbye.
Perhaps she could help with your little problem.  Martin has a phobia of blood.
Why don't you find another complete stranger and tell them all about my childhood bed wetting?
Twelve is hardly childhood, Martin.
Might be worth a try.  Don't want to bang my own trumpet, but I do get quite speedy results.  Only yesterday I had this
bitch who proved to be very stubborn, but I soon sorted her out.
You're a dog trainer?
Dog psychologist.  It's all the same, really.  Simply a matter of rewiring the brain.
Restrain that animal.  Or analyze its unhappy childhood.
Martin
Clive
Why don't you look where you're going?
I'm going to the recycling.  Why do you ask?
Clive
Joe
Hit the ground.  Splat!  Put "splat."
Do you mind?
Paramedic
Martin
Paramedic
Martin
Paramedic
Martin
Oh, nasty.
Oh, that's your medical opinion, is it?
Ah, you'd better come with us.
I'm fine!
Ah - that's gonna need stitches.  You gonna do them yourself?
Yes.  No.
Martin
Nurse
Martin
Nurse
A simple, uninterrupted suture, yes?
Yes.
Not too tight.  Don't want to cut off the blood supply.
Do you want to finish this yourself?  
Edith
Martin
Edith
Ellingham.
Edith.  (gag)
Bad pasty?
Martin
Edith
What are you doing in Truro?
Well, I, um…I was going to examine my patient, but let's have a catch-up instead.  
Edith
Martin
Edith
Nurse said your GP reported you were experiencing abdominal pain.  Where is he?
I'm here.
Right.
Mrs Tishell
Clive
Mrs Tishell
Clive
18 years.
How long is it now? 16?  17 years?
We've been married 18 years! 18!
Don't seem that long, do it?
Mrs Tishell
Martin
Clive
Martin
Clive
Martin
Clive
Martin
Clive
Martin
Mrs Tishell
Clive
Martin
Clive
Martin
Oh! Doctor Ellingham!
You could have caused a serious accident yesterday afternoon.
Like I told PC Penhale, it wasn't my fault.
You are irresponsible and a danger to the public!
You can't talk to me like that!
Have you had your ears examined?
No!  There's no point!
Then you need to call my receptionist and make an appointment before you cause any more accidents.
No!
Yes!
Please Clive!
There's no need!
I'm trying to help you!
I don't need help!
The very fact that we are all shouting surely proves that you do!
Pauline
I'm never gonna sleep again.  They shouldn't have kicked him out of the army for snoring.  They should have kept him
in and used him as a weapon of mass destruction.
Edith
Pauline
Edith
Pauline
Edith
Pauline
Edith
Pauline
Dr Ellingham, please.
He's with a patient.
I'll see him next.
Oh, so you're Chippy Miller, the crabman?
What?
You don't have an appointment.
I'm Dr Montgomery.
I'm Pauline, the receptionist.
Martin
Mother
Martin
There really is no way of knowing.  Perhaps weeks.  If she's one of the lucky ones.
You hear about this, but you never think it's gonna happen to you.
It's head lice, woman.  Not leukemia.
Martin
Pauline!  Control this child!  Who let this dog in here?  Where's my aunt?  
Edith
Martin
It's nice.  Do they pay you in chickens?
Hmmm.  You just passing?  
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith

Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
It's been awhile.  Twenty years.
See you still like impractical footwear. What were you doing in Truro?
One day a week.  Common obstetrics.  Gathering data.  I run a private fertility clinic next door.
Married?
Not long enough for there to be any permanent damage.  You?
No.  Isn't it customary to write a letter outlining your diagnosis rather than reporting in person?
Then I wouldn't have been able to poke around in your underwear drawer. I heard whispers of a surgeon with
haemophobia.
Did you?
How are you finding General Practice?
Busy.
Right.  Have you lost your edge Ellingham?
Are you trying to diagnose me?
I don't have to, do I?
Bert
The catch of the day is Sea Bream.  The soup is leek and potato.  The vegetarian option is…also leek and potato.  It's
a big day for leeks.  And potatoes.  
Chris
Martin
Chris
Martin
Chris
Martin
Chris
Martin
Chris
Martin
Chris

Martin
Chris
Martin
Chris
Martin
Chris
Martin
Chris
Martin
Chris
Martin
Martin.
Chris.
What happened there?
Oh, nothing. So, who's complained about me now?
Look, can’t I just drop in on an old mate?
Was it Mr Turnbull or Mrs Felcher?
Mr Walton.
Oh.
He says you called him a mentally deficient parasite.
He IS a mentally deficient parasite.
Fair enough. The man complains about every little thing.  Right.  I've spoken to you.  Complaint dealt with at chief-
executive level.  Job done.  So, how have you been?
Consultations are up 5%.
How have YOU been?
Um, well, I suppose things are all right.  Could be better.
Yes?
Well, since you ask...I'm beginning to think that, uh, perhaps my time here is at an end.
You mean yo want to move practices?
No.  I'm thinking of going back into surgery.
And you're ready?  I mean, your problem...
I'm working on it.
Well, do you want me to see what's out there?
Yes.  Yes, I do.
Martin

Barbara
Martin
Barbara
Martin
Barbara
Martin
Barbara
Martin
Barbara
Martin
You had the MRI.  It showed a mass in your abdomen.  You had the CT scan.  That confirmed a cyst.  And now she's
going to operate.  It's quite straightforward.
Uh, no.  I don’t think so.
You don’t think so, what?
I don’t think they did all those things.
Of course they did.  It's the standard procedure.  That;s how other conditions are ruled out.
CT scan.  They didn't do that.
Yes, they did.
Big machine.  With the rotating thing?  I mean, I'd remember something like that.
There was no CT scan?
Don't mean to be annoying.  I'm sure it's not important, but I...
You can't help being annoying.  And yes, it is important.
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Montgomery.
You didn’t order a CT scan on Barbara Collingsworth.
Correct.
You should have.
I think not.
So, how did you rule out diverticulitis?  Women's intuition?
Experience.
It doesn't necessarily have to be a cyst.
Mind your own business.  This isn't your case.
Could be a diverticular mass, which would be easily treatable with antibiotics.
I'm afraid you've lost me with all those long words.
Your diagnosis is premature.
Stick to the sore throats and diarrhea and leave the surgery to the grown-ups.
Pauline
If my brother doesn't leave soon, I'm gonna murder him.  Probably fall asleep halfway through, though.
Pauline
Bed.  The final frontier.
Clive
What could be better?  You, me, and the sea.  We'll have an eternity of time together.  Just you and me.  
Clive
Mrs Tishell
Clive
Mrs Tishell
Clive
Mrs Tishell
Same again?
Oh, just an orange juice.
Sorry?
Orange juice.
Come again?
Brandy!  I'll have a double brandy!  
Old Woman
Martin
Would you help me, please?
No.
Martin
Edith
Martin

Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin

Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith.
Hello.
The Collingsworth woman.  Lower-abdominal pain. Elevated temperature.  Complained of nausea.  You've made a
diagnostic leap and assumed that it's a cyst without taking a proper look and ruling out diverticulitis.
Sorry.  What were you saying?
Which is treated with antibiotics rather than charging in with an invasive and potentially harmful procedure.
You miss playing with all the machines, don't you Ellingham?
How many years have you been a specialist?
Seventeen.  I've seen this presentation of symptoms more times than I can count.
Do you think all those years might have narrowed your vision, and you're only capable of seeing a gynecological
solution?
I have to scrub up.
Edith.  I wasn't going to interfere out of respect for you.  But you leave me no alternative.  I must insist that you
authorize a CT scan.
She's my patient Ellingham.  You can't insist.  
Martin
Nurse
Martin
Nurse
Martin
Nurse
Radiographer
Martin
Patient needs a CT scan.  Lower abdomen.
Uh, so do they.
Get on the bed.
Uh, don't get on the bed.
It's an emergency.
Who are you?  What do you think you're doing?
Uh, listen mate.  There's a bloody queue.  And you belong at the back of it.
Fine.  I'm sure that Dr Montgomery will enjoy operating blind.  And when she nicks this woman's bowel, you can explain
it to her family's lawyers!  Get on the bed.  
Edith
Martin
Edith

Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Wasn't hard to find you Ellingham.  I just followed the trail of outraged people.
Hello Edith.
You hijack my patient and perform an unauthorized procedure in a hospital where you have no privileges.  If you
weren't already an obscure GP in the back end of nowhere, you certainly would be by the time I'm finished with you.
It's a diverticular mass.
Right.  Good news Mrs Collinsworth.  No need for surgery.
No apology?
Well spotted.
Martin
Shouldn't you be dozing at your desk?
Adam
Martin
Adam
Pauline
Martin
Pauline
Adam
Pauline
Adam
Pauline
Martin
How do you get a perforated septum?
Any sharp object will do.
Pauline stuck a lollipop stick up my nose.
You were five.
You perforated his septum.
Whatever. He buried My Little Pony.
It's your fault I got kicked out of the army.  All my life I've wanted to serve my nation, protect my country.
Don't tell mum.
I so am!
Oh...Thanks a bunch Doc!
Ah yes.  Obviously I'm the one at fault.  
Clive
Martin
Clive
Martin
Mrs Tishell
You mean it can be cured?
Yes.  And your hearing can be restored.
I'll be able to go back to work?
Yes.
Oh, what a shame!  I mean...a...not having you around all the time.
Mrs Tishell
Martin
So, Clive will be gone soon.  Back to his job.  Far away.  And I'll be on my own again.
Good.
Martin
Right, I see.  Well, that sounds promising.  Wh - when would they want me to start?  Yes.  Well, uh, tell them I'm
interested.  Definitely interested.  
Al
Pauline
Al
Pauline

Al
So, the only way you'll move in is if I win you in a game like a, a goldfish or...
Exactly.  
You could just ask nicely.
I am stone.  Got it?  Stone.  Three, two.  Again.  Three, two.  No, I... Three, two.  Three, two.  Oh, just give me the
bloody keys!
You're dead predictable, you are.  Dead predictble.
Martin
Edith

Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
I accept your apology.
Thank you. What you did was deeply patronizing and violated protocol.  I'd expect nothing less.  You haven't changed
Ellingham.
Neither have you. Have a seat.
Thank you.  How's the hand?
I haven't looked.
What happened?
Some utter moron.
Another one.  
Edith
Martin

Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
Edith
Martin
I always thought you'd end up somewhere...else.
You assume this is some sort of purgatory.  In March the local farmers have a competition to see who most resembles
their pig.  And for the last two years, they have petitioned me to be the judge.
Mmm.
It's considered an honor.
Well, that explains why you stay here then.
Hmmm.  As a matter of fact, Chris Parsons has contacted me about a post at Imperial.  Head of vascular.
Oh.  Right.  What about your problem?
I'm dealing with it.
But, even this is making you queasy.
No it isn't.
Martin
Louisa
Martin
Louisa
Louisa.
Hello Martin.
How are you?  You're pregnant!
Yes.  I am.  
.
.
MARTIN & LOUISA
Louisa is nowhere to be seen during most of this episode.  At one point, right after Bert has been teasing him about Martin having a "piece
missing", he has to run to the school for a medical emergency.  After dealing with the emergency, he is walking through the school corridor
and stops dead in his tracks.  He goes right up to the window in the door of the classroom and stares at the teacher he can only see from
behind.  She has her dark hair up in a ponytail and is wearing a salmon colored sweater just like one that Louisa wore.  He starts to open the
door, slamming into a student standing there and the teacher turns to face him - revealing a young woman who looks nothing like Louisa.
Martin is sitting in his kitchen with Edith and she is examining the wound on the palm of his hand.  He stands up to go get antiseptic when
there is a knock on the kitchen door.  He opens the door and is shocked to see Louisa standing there.  He says, "Louisa."  She smiles and
says, "Hello Martin."  He asks, "How are you?" and then his eyes drop down and he looks back at her face in shock, "You're pregnant."  
Louisa sort of bites her lip, says, "Yes, I am" and smiles at him.  

To be continued...
.
..
.
.
Click thumbnails for full sized pictures
.
.
WARDROBE
.
.
.
.
..
.
.
RECEPTIONIST
.
..
Click thumbnails for full sized pictures
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.